Honest Opinion: Does the Ring Look Horrible?
Hey everyone! š
Iām excited to share my engagement ring with you all today. This is such a supportive community, and I canāt wait to hear your thoughts! But before we dive in, I have to be honest: Iām feeling a bit uncertain about my ring. So here goes nothing!
Drumroll, please… š„
Picture attached
So, this beauty is a [describe your ring: e.g., a round cut diamond set in a vintage-inspired halo, with a rose gold band]. I was instantly drawn to its [mention specific features like sparkle, design, etc.], and it felt perfect when my fiancĆ© proposed. But now that the adrenaline has worn off, I find myself wondering if itās really me.
Why the Doubts?
I think itās normal to have mixed feelings about such a big purchase. After all, engagement rings are not just pieces of jewelry; they represent promises and love. But itās easy to get lost in the social media feeds filled with breathtaking rings and flawless settings.
Am I just caught up in comparison? Is there a fine line between āuniqueā and āwhat was I thinking?ā š¤
Your Thoughts?
That’s where Iād love your input! I genuinely want to know:
- Does the ring look horrendous, or is it just my nerves talking?
- What design elements do you think make a ring truly stand out (in a good way or a bad way)?
- Are there any specific styles or settings that might age poorly or are simply a trend?
And while weāre at it, feel free to share your own rings or those youāve seen that you love (or didn’t quite love).
Letās Share Experiences!
Weāre all here to celebrate engagements, learn about gems, cuts, and settings, and of course, show off those stunning pieces. Whether youāre rocking a bold statement ring or a delicate little band, every piece tells a story.
Canāt wait to hear what you all think! Remember, honest opinions are welcomeājust keep it constructive. š
Happy sharing!
ā [Your Name]
I think it’s very pretty, what don’t you like about it?
What are you thinking looks horrible?
My MIL has diamonds going all the way around like that. She said while she loves her ring she wishes she had chosen a band with diamonds only half way down because they rub against her skin.
Other than that I find it to be a beautiful ring.
That center stone will not stay tight in that setting unfortunately
I think itās absolutely beautiful. Literally Stunning
I think it looks absolutely gorgeous
What? Absolutely not. That’s gorgeous!
Horrible, no. Incredibly susceptible to the stone being dislodged without a gallery rail? Yes.
The only thing it needs is a guard rail. Otherwise it is a gorgeous ring. Idk what made you think it looked horrible.
No. Why? Itās beautiful Iāll take it if you donāt want it
Itās beautiful! My only concern is it sits a little high for my liking- but itās gorgeous
It’s very top-heavy.
It looks gorgeous but definitely need a guard rail/hidden halo. Seems like you don’t like how square it is? What is the ratio of the stone? Usually if you want more elongated emerald cut then 1.45 ratio is the best (L/W) for elongated.
it looks lovely but that diamond is definitely not secure
I think it’s beautiful. And in my amateur opinion the main stone may need more support
No I think thatās a beautiful classic type of ring
Quite the contrary actually. It is gorgeous.
Absolutely gorgeous and study looking
Too high set but itās pretty
I don’t think it’s horrible, but I will say if you have so much of your center stone exposed away from the setting, you will notice the stone itself getting dirtier more often. Not a big deal if you don’t mind cleaning your ring often, but just an FYI š
I think it is beautiful! My only issue would be that it is really tall and I would hit it on everything, so *I* wouldnāt like this. But thatās just me, because I am slightly clumsy and my spatial awareness sucks. I guess it depends on the person who will be wearing it uses their hands daily.
It looks prone to damage in a couple of ways but visually I think it’s beautiful
Itās gorgeous but itās giving me anxiety because it looks like is gonna fall.
Iām no expert. But I believe it needs a gallery rail. The stone isnāt very secure. Pretty though
Horrible? I canāt tell if youāre being facetious.
No, itās beautiful
You need a rail gallery! Those 4 prongs make me nervous.
It looks nicely made but I think the stone could be lowered a bit to make it not as high profile. Also a gallery rail would really be best for the longevity of the ring.
It looks horribly unsafe
Needs a gallery rail to hold that stone in. Otherwise is very pretty!
This is gorgeous but I love a chubby emerald. I would add a gallery rail though.
The general design is lovely, pave settings are hit or miss for me and I like this. However that basket setting is a big red flag. The big gap between the centre stone / diamond and where the metal strands meet the shank should not be there. It will not stay tight and will be prone to damage.
That is quite literally stunning. But I do worry about the center stone staying tight.
I think itās really pretty however it does look like it sits too high in my opinion
Looks great. Get it insured!