Is This a Good Deal for $850? Let’s Discuss Engagement Rings!
Hello, fellow ring enthusiasts! 💍
I recently came across a stunning engagement ring, and I couldn’t resist the urge to share it with you all. Priced at $850, it has sparked my curiosity about whether this is truly a good deal or if I should keep looking. Here’s what I found:
The Details:
- Center Stone: 1.00-carat round diamond
- Cut: Ideal cut with excellent symmetry
- Color: G-H (near-colorless)
- Clarity: VS2 (very slight inclusions)
- Setting: 14k white gold with delicate pavé setting around the band
- Certification: GIA-certified (always a good sign!)
Why This Caught My Eye:
-
Quality of the Stone: The ideal cut means that it should reflect light beautifully, maximizing sparkle. Diamonds that are well-cut often appear larger and more brilliant than their carat weight would suggest.
-
Certification: GIA certification adds a layer of reassurance. It’s a recognized standard in the industry, signifying that the diamond has been evaluated using established criteria.
-
Aesthetic Appeal: The pavé setting adds a modern touch, offering a bit of extra sparkle without being overwhelming.
Discussion Points:
Now, I want to hear from you! Is $850 a fair price for a ring with these specifications? Here are some points to consider:
-
Market Trends: How does this price compare to the current market value for similar rings? Should I be looking into local jewelry stores or online retailers for price comparisons?
-
Resale Value: If this were to be an investment piece, how would its resale value hold up? Does a setting matter in deciding the future worth?
-
Ethics of Sourcing: What’s your take on the importance of ethical sourcing? Should I pay more for a sustainably sourced diamond, or is that secondary to the diamond’s beauty and quality?
-
Personal Preferences: In your opinion, does the style and setting influence your decision more than the diamond itself? How do you balance aesthetic appeal with quality?
-
Future Purchases: For those of you who have engaged recently, what factors did you consider when buying your rings? Would you have opted for a different cut or metal if given a second chance?
Share Your Thoughts!
I’m excited to hear your insights and to dive into this conversation with all of you! Whether you’ve been through the ring-buying journey yourself or have experiences to share from family and friends, your voices are invaluable in this community.
So, is this a good deal for $850? Let’s get the discussion flowing! ✨

It’s a really pretty design, but $850 feels a bit high for a 0.25 ct aquamarine and small accent diamonds. You could probably find something similar in 18k gold for around $500–650 unless it’s handmade or from a well-known jeweler.
No
Check out KTRingcraft on Etsy: https://www.etsy.com/ca/listing/1376973618/?ref=share_ios_native_control
He made my engagement ring and wedding ring. I’m sure he can source aquamarine if that’s what you’re looking for! He made my wedding ring from a reference photo.
The price of gold is really high right now, so this isn’t too ridiculously far off. Sure, you could probably get a better deal on something similar from somewhere else by a hundred or few, but if you’ve found a ring you both love… why penny pinch? I may be in the minority here but I think for a lifetime of joy looking at the ring it should be the one you want and to a certain point, the “best deal” doesn’t matter.
Depending on the weight of the setting, yeah, it’s probably fair because gold is so high right now.
Not sure if it’s a good deal but it’s beautiful!
Gold, yes , silver no
I wouldn’t want this
That feels like highway robbery for a .25 carat aquamarine.
This looks like the Disney engagement ring for Elsa by Peoples Jewelers